Yeah, I can see that - the worth toxics I've seen are junk tier, Wal-Mart shelf gloves, but maybe they make better ones too under the same name since when I googled it now they did have a full grain version...You really don't have to go top end (though I love my A2000), but make sure you get one that would normally be at least around 70-80 bucks regular price, even if you get it for 40-50 online or on sale.
Make sure you go at least 13" length for outfield, as you want the extra surface area for running catches, and make sure the palm at least is full grain leather, not one of these ones made of fabric and foam with a paper thin layer of leather overtop of it that tears away in 2 weeks.
I had one of these a few years back and loved it- great value for the cheap price, full grain leather and a comfortable all around glove. A couple guys on my team are still rocking these too.
It's still a good glove today after two seasons full time duty, but I upgraded as it was starting to get a little floppier than I like in the fingers on grounder pickups as the lower end gloves tend to do.
Bottom line: if you're only looking to spend 50-100 bucks on a glove for a couple years, this one would be one of my top recommendations.
They're discontinued, but if you can find a Louisville Slugger Evolution series glove, I highly recommend them. Steer hide and American made, they hold up very nicely. They were over $200 when first introduced.
I used one of these gloves and love it. They were like $150 gloves last year, they stopped this model and now they're cheaper in price. Super high end glove though.
I have two and they're both mizuno. this one for outfield because it has more padding. and this one for middle infield because the leather is softer. I lucked out and found the MVP for $50 at sports authority.
It's the Mizuno Prime SE 12.75" outfield glove in red/royal color way.