What is Reddit's opinion of
Compare-N-Save 75324 Herbicide, 1-gallon, white?
From 3.5 billion Reddit comments
By popularity on Reddit, this product is:
33 reviews of this product found across Reddit:
Chemical, glyphosate. Compare n save
I spayed 2 times, early August and mid August. For the front/side yards this fall I am going to do nearly the same thing....but I actually have some grass there already so will not go all out. However two things I am definitely going to do this time different is: 1) Do 1 round of glyphosate, then power rake, then do the 2nd round of glyphosate and 2) Use tenacity when I seed.
The split of glyphosate is because after power raking I think seeds were turned up a bit and germinated. If I rake and then wait to see new growth and knock it again its just that much less competition with the grass seeds starting.
Appreciate the quick response.
Here's what I'm ordering from Amazon - 41%
Is that strong enough?
Thanks again.
Something like this I believe is usually recommended. But I would just search for glyphosate concentrate on Amazon and find the best deal for the amount you need. Glyphosate is the active ingredient in roundup no reason to pay for the name. Especially if you are just nuking an area and not worried about grass.
Better to get https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ARKS3XO and dilute yourself. It’s the same active ingredient. You won’t need to buy more for many years. It can also kill small trees if you don’t dilute it, which is nice if you can’t remove the stump.
Just don’t get it on your skin. It’s a known carcinogen.
https://www.amazon.com/Compare-N-Save-Concentrate-41-Percent-Glyphosate-1-Gallon/dp/B00ARKS3XO/ref=sr_1_3?keywords=weed+killer&qid=1561669243&s=gateway&sr=8-3 this is the best weed killer I have found. Literally kill anything it touches and a little goes a long way.
When it gets warmer, water your lawn for a week, and blast anything that grows with round up (glyphosate). Water it again, and blast anything else that pops up.
Be sure to use a surfactant like dish soap. Round up from the big box stores might already have a surfactant.
You should install an irrigation system asap.
As for the grass type, you should see what your neighbors are using. Check out the lawns of the more wealthy neighborhoods, and see what they are growing.
Bermuda and St Augustine are generally not seeded. People use plugs or sod. I know UC Buffalo grass is the same.
If you want to seed a cool season grass like tall fescue, you have a small window to seed it in the early spring. Or you can wait until fall.
I used this to kill
I didn't keep exact track of everything but some of the supplies I ordered on Amazon and my friend sold me the seed for $40 so I'm guessing that was a deal. I have the bag still so I need to look it up and find what it would have cost.
This is the exact stuff I used, however I paid about $16 USD for a US gallon at Menards, one of our regional big box home improvement stores.
I tried to look up glyphosate using amazon.ca - not having the best of luck. Is Roundup legal up there?
You may be right - and seems logical. However, the saplings and vines I used it on haven't shown green growth since applying this spring.
Nuke the lawn with glyphosate, water the lawn, then glyphosate any weeds that come up.
Then rake away all the dead. Start with a clean slate of dirt only.
Then install sprinklers, aerate, fertilize, and seed. However if you are in a snowy climate, it may be too late to plant cool season grasses.
Wait until the next season. Or plant warm season grass in late may.
Oooh, don't buy ready to use. It's usually much more diluted. I recommend this mixed a little over a 2% ratio. Also, you can add a splash/shot of vinegar to the mix if your city has hard water.
Solarization takes a long time. I don't recommend it unless you're planning your renovation for next year.
Not familiar with KillzAll, but with any weed and grass killer the active ingredient you're looking for is glyphosate. Roundup is the most popular brand name, or you can go with a generic if you have a sprayer and you want to mix it up yourself. It's more bang for your buck that way. Keep in mind that this will kill everything that's green--weeds, trees, shrubs, desirable grasses, everything. And it's absorbed through the leafy green parts, so if you spray it on a tree trunk it won't do anything.
It can pose a danger for pets, but only if it can get into their systems. Once dry, contact danger is not a problem and they'll be able to run and romp on it to their hearts' content. Keeping them off the grass on the day you spray is enough. Then the only thing you'll have to worry about is them eating enough of the greens that have absorbed it to build up a concentration in their system, which is almost never a problem.
For what it's worth, I've done this with both my front and back yards in my yard renovation, and my dog is fine.
Also, timelines:
- Some sources say that glypohsate has a 7-day window, meaning that if you spray it on a Friday, you'll be safe to plant again the following Saturday. I always give it a 30 day window, just to be safe. I'm a little paranoid.
- It will take 14 days for the glyphosate to act. You'll start seeing results somewhere on days 10-12. Don't get discouraged that it isn't instant.
- Drying/absorption time is 2-8 hours depending on sunlight, temperature, and humidity.
Edit: typos
Amazon also has the grass killer Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer, 41-Percent Glyphosate, 1-Gallon https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ARKS3XO/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_ml32xbG1K04JP
Yes haha, sorry!
I use this concentrate from Amazon with the suggested sprayer. Just be careful so you don't spray plants you want to keep, it basically kills anything that is green.
​
this is the exact stuff i used. 41% glyphosate.
https://www.amazon.com/Compare-N-Save-Concentrate-41-Percent-Glyphosate-1-Gallon/dp/B00ARKS3XO
Just contact the neighbor and ask if he minds if you just spray it over the fence, or even come into his yard and spray for him. My go-to mixture which works quite well is:
- 6oz/gallon Glyphosate (AKA Round-up)
- 12oz/gallon Pramitol
- (optional) 1oz/gallon Triclopyr
This mixture will permanently kill anything with roots and leaves and will sterilize the ground so nothing else grows for at least a few weeks.. Be advised that also includes large trees so if the poison ivy is around the base of a 50 year old elm tree, definitely remove the Pramitol and Triclopyr and just stick with the Glyphosate.
I should note that I am also an (obsessive) amateur and I've almost exclusively dealt with invasive shrubs and larger vines, so I'm just dipping my toes in to chemical control of other plants.
If it were my land, what I'd do is "cut stump" all of the larger climbing vines with 20% glyphosate/water ASAP since those are likely to broadcast the most seed and cause continuing major issues. I've used this stuff in a 50/50 mix with DI water to good effect on wintercreeper: https://www.amazon.com/Compare-N-Save-Concentrate-41-Percent-Glyphosate-1-Gallon/dp/B00ARKS3XO
Then I would mow/weed whack CONSISTENTLY as much as you could for about a summer and see how much that reduces, and from there either continue maintaining mechanically if you have the energy, or do a foliar spray when the infestation is (hopefully) a lot smaller.
Keep in mind that you'll need to stay on top of it for at least a few years and go out every couple of months to find any that have started growing from the seed bank. If you're effective and the forested area is somewhat mature and not totally wrecked you should have minimal issues after about 5 years. This seems like a long time, but you'll be surprised at how quickly it goes by, and how satisfying it is to restore and area!
Cheapest would be this. You will need a sprayer or spray bottle.
You will also need to add a surfactant. You can add a few drops of dish washing liquid. Or you can buy a surfactant.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ARKS3XO/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_30xnFbDTFZ9S1
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004XDHRCE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_z3xnFbA0V1BSJ
You would also need a sprayer to apply it. You can apply it up to the same day you seed. Be liberal with it, it won't harm your soil.
i have a gravel front yard and my whole side yard and 1/3 of my back yard is also gravel. in other words, i have a lot of gravel/rock. i use this cheap glyphosate i get on amazon. i spray once in the early spring. and once in the late summer. it lasts like 3months per treament in my case. i pretty much have no weeds in my rock. every once in a while i see one sprout and hand pick it. it's been great. i do live in an area that does have 4 seasons, so you may have to use yours once per season. make sure you don't get any on your bushes. cause this stuff kills pretty much everything.
https://www.amazon.com/Compare-N-Save-Concentrate-41-Percent-Glyphosate-1-Gallon/dp/B00ARKS3XO
The Amazon price is what I'm referring to. For example, this 1 gallon glyphosate product (41%) is only $20. If we compare that to this RoundUp Pro Concentrate 2.5 gallon 50.2% glyphosate product, the RoundUp is still much more expensive per gram of glyphosate. Is the RoundUp better for other reasons, or is the cheaper stuff just as good, assuming you mix the end-product to the same concentration?
Weedkiller man. Easy. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ARKS3XO/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1 a fraction of the cost of retail stores, just get a sprayer and go to town.
If you want peace, nuke your lawn with glyphosate to shut them up.
What grass do you have down?
I put down mainly tall fescue with some bluegrass. I can tell you exactly tomorrow if interested.
Also does not seeding in the spring (for cool season grasses, anyways) still apply when temps are going high this early?
Yea, I wouldn't put any seed down right now. It won't make it through the summer.
I'm a fellow NCer and there's a few parts of my lawn that definitely need seeding. I'm worried that if I aerate, topdress, fertilize, and water now, and don't seed until the fall, that parts will remain bare because there is just nothing to grow.
I would only work on leveling/filling holes right now. Wait till fall then kill everything including your grass, I used This that will give you a clean slate, don't want weeds lingering. If you want to aerate do that around sept. Then seed and all that.
I didn't aerate, I bought soil conditioner/microbes and sprayed that around seeding time.microbes
Also if you live near NC State they will give you a free soil test. I didn't do it but I will this year.
So that's about it for now, let me know if you have any other questions.
Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer, 41-Percent Glyphosate, 1-Gallon https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ARKS3XO/ref=cm_sw_r_other_apa_mexZxbH8GH1A7
Where do you live? It's hard to make recommendations without knowing this information but I can give you my knowledge from my experience. I live in the northwest US and about a year ago I completely re-did my backyard. Here's basically the process I used:
- Cut grass as short as you can.
- Use herbicide with 41-Percent Glyphosate like this.
- Wait 2-3 weeks. Rake out dead weeds/grass. May need to till depending on soil.
- Most people will tell you you should get a soil test done in case you need to amend the soil. Not always necessary though.
- Amend soil as needed.
- Rake soil flat. You may find something like this useful. Remove any remaining large chunks of dirt and grass.
- Wait until early-mid September, throw down grass seed. It is recommended to have ~20 seeds per square inch, but that's actually quite a bit so just do your best to put a lot down, evenly.
- Lite raking to mix in seeds with dirt.
- Put a good 1/4-1/2" of peat moss over-top of all seeds.
- Water. Don't let the seeds dry out. First 2-3 weeks you should water 2-3 times a day depending on weather.
Let me know if you have any questions, I'll do my best to help you out.
You can kill everything off with a glyphosate product. RoundUp is the brand name, but you can also get a generic one and use it with a pump sprayer (properly mixed and diluted, of course) to get more bang for your buck.
Things you should do:
- Whenever you want, kill everything off. Just make sure it's at least two weeks before you put down seed
- Sometime in the next month or two, get your soil test done
- In July or August, get your seed
- As soon as feasible, figure out an irrigation plan for dry periods
- When you have free time, watch some videos by the Lawn Care Nut. Watch the videos from before he moved to Florida. Those will be the most applicable to you.
Generic is substantially cheaper with same active ingredient. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ARKS3XO/ref=cm_sw_r_awd_v.HVvb15H4C2Q
Yup, clone brand "Compare-N-Save" http://www.amazon.com/Compare-N-Save-Concentrate-41-Percent-Glyphosate-1-Gallon/dp/B00ARKS3XO
Roundup is insanely expensive and I have a big yard so I use this generic "Roundup Pro" from Tractor Supply Company. It's virtually identical to Roundup Pro concentrate being 41% glyphosate plus a surfactent, but costs around 1/5th the price. Works great, have used it for the last dozen years.
I mix it 3 oz. per gallon of water which is a fairly strong mix, so if you go that strong, watch where you're spraying carefully.
Dispose of the mixed product left in your sprayer within two or three days because if it sits longer, it coagulates and will wreak havoc on your sprayer requiring disassembly and cleaning. Unmixed and in the original container, the product is stable and effective for years. One big jug like this will last me 2-3 years controlling weeds and fenceline grass on 2.5 acres.
I just had Tractor Supply deliver a new jug of it the other day since I'm not big on going out with COVID-19 in progress. I think the delivery fee was around $15.
Edit: Same stuff, different brand, smaller jug for $22 including delivery on Amazon.
I've got a half acre in Virginia where the weeds sometimes need a good nuking from orbit. Concocted a mix to spray which does a great job, if not overkill:
- 1 cup 41% glyphosphate
- 1 cup 61% triclopyr
- 1 tablespoon surfactant (dish soap works, supposedly)
- 1 tablespoon ammonium sulfate (encourages plant absorption)
Add the above to a 1-gallon sprayer and fill up with water. Again, this is probably overkill, but it works like a champ.
Popular alternatives to Compare-N-Save 75324 Herbic...
BIOADVANCED 704140 All-in-One Lawn Weed And Crabgrass Killer Garden Herbicide, 40-Ounce, Concentrate
