I'm currently a big fan of the Distl Union Wally, I just wish the leather was a bit higher quality. Been carrying it for about a year now and it's already showing lots of fade where the corners of the card rub. Haven't found one I like better. Definitely not a BIFL candidate.
I was just in your shoes as my former wallet was falling apart. After a decent amount of research I settled on the Distil Union Wally (link. I've only had it for about two weeks but it's been great thus far. It's a bit on the minimal side, but I had gotten really tired of sitting on a big wad of cards, cash, and receipts all day, so it's been nice to go the other direction.
Did you have a particular style you were looking for?
TOP LEFT BOX: THINGS GEAR HEADS CARRY
TOP RIGHT BOX: THINGS EVERYONE CARRIES
Google Pixel XL
Car Keys on Nite Ize S Biners
House Keys on Keysmart Rugged
BOTTOM BOXES: THINGS LOTS OF PEOPLE CARRY
Cheap Sunglasses
5.11 Tactical Cap
Distil Union Wally Bifold Slim Leather Wallet. Can hold a couple to many cards - my favorite wallet ever! https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01M8MFWXS/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_xwYAybXE10VSK