What is Reddit's opinion of
Electrical Machines, Drives and Power Systems?
From 3.5 billion Reddit comments
By popularity on Reddit, this product is:
9 reviews of this product found across Reddit:
I did an EET program in Canada before EE on power systems. We used Electrical Machines, Drives and Power Systems. It covers the operation and application of 3 phase, transformer, motors and alternators plus more industrial stuff. Doesn't get deep into the design but focuses more on the practical explaining the machines and what you'd need to know to work with them without getting into math past phasors.
Here is the book I used for my Energy Devices class, I found it really useful for most anything that you would come across on a beginner level. Electrical Machines, Drives, and Power Systems
Electric machines, drives and power systems by Theodore Wildi. This is the book I used for my EET program. It'll go in depth into 3 phase, different types of motor & generator applications and operation, different transformer configurations and power systems stuff more tailored at utilities. There's also control and plc stuff in there too. It's very practical but there's still a lot of math and it's about as deep as you can go before you need calculus. You'll need to learn complex numbers and how those relate to phasors to understand it.
For my technologist program focusing on power systems (Canada) we used Electrical Machines, Drives, and Power Systems. It covers industrial control, generators, motors, power electronics, transformers, utilities and some PLC. It's qualitative and focuses on application, construction and operation. It does contain math but it stops at complex algebra for analysis with phasors. Not sure what level you're interested in refreshing but it can go pretty in depth with some heavy readings. I'm in eng school now and although it's not quite an engineering textbook, it kinda falls under the requested categories.
I haven't read the book /u/logosogol posted, but I had this book for school and it's pretty in-depth, with a decent amount of AC/DC fundamentals as well. Sometimes it gets a bit involved but it is mostly pretty practical.
The following books are frequently recommended as study sources for the Electrical Power PE exam. Price tags are scary on the new side, but most of these are common college textbooks, so there's plenty of used copies floating around. Older editions are also fine (physics doesn't change much between years):
Electrical Machines, Drives and Power Systems by Theodore Wildi
Power System Analysis and Design by Glover, Sarma, and Overbye
Electric Machinery and Power System Fundamentals by Stephen Chapman
Linden's Handbook of Batteries
Power System Analysis by Grainger, Stevenson
Engineering Economic Analysis by Newnan, Lavelle, Eschenbach
And, of course, a copy of the electrical bible:
I took this exam in California (San Mateo) and I am an Ohio Resident so that meant air travel and space considerations. That's important because the number of references, for me, was limited as I was not willing to chance them travelling in a checked bag.
First, a little background: I started as an industrial electrician in 2006. I pursued my engineering degree part time starting in 2008. I earned my AS in 2012 and BS in 2015. I began working in the engineering space in 2011 at a consulting firm, then moved on to a large OEM then finally found myself at a power engineering and services company.
This exam is not easy but it doesn't have to be brutal if you can properly prepare yourself. Take it seriously and you'll be fine.
My study schedule was more haphazard than most. I have 2 kids (8yo and 3yo) and an otherwise active lifestyle so finding the time meant just grabbing what free hours were available, when they were available. Basically, I studied for 1-2 hours a night (no less than every other night) for the 4 months leading up to the exam. 1 month out, I set aside 4 hours on a Saturday and 4 hours on a Sunday and did the NCEES practice test in two parts to assess my status. From there I focused my efforts on problem areas. All in, I believe I had some 200-250 hours if I include some pre-studying before the 4 month mark.
My primary resource was Engineering Pro Guides. I used the Technical Study Guide as the guiding document and supplemented with other resources. I used all of the following throughout studying but they are listed in order of importance relative to exam day:
- ENG Pro Guide Technical Study Guide -- https://www.engproguides.com/power-pe-exam-study-guide-tools.html
- Get all of his practice tests. They are very, very good.
- The Electrical Engineer's Guide to Passing the Power PE Exam by Graffeo -- http://www.powerpeexamguide.com/
- National Electric Code, non-handbook (I was an electrician before so I didn't need the extra weight of the handbook) -- https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/national-electrical-code-2017-edition-nfpa/1123827199#/
- I'd get the tabs for this no matter your level of familiarity
- Electrical Machines, Drives and Power Systems by Wildi -- https://www.amazon.com/Electrical-Machines-Drives-Power-Systems/dp/0131776916
- Power System Analysis by Grainger -- https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/power-system-analysis-john-j-grainger/1100151989
- I didn't use this one much on the exam but there are some odd ball items in here that can be helpful
- National Electric Safety Code -- https://catalog.nfpa.org/National-Electrical-Safety-Code-2017-Edition-P17436.aspx
- Try to borrow this one if you can as its expensive but there are not likely to be a lot of questions needing it. Easy points if you have the book though.
- Various printouts bound in 3-ring binders for topics I struggled with but weren't well covered in the above. For example, battery calculations, certain power electronics, certain equipment standards, etc.
Like I mentioned above, I was an electrician before I got into engineering so my base code knowledge was above average. That said, ENG Pro Guides has an excellent practice test. Find your way through that a couple of times and you should be fine. The key is to learn how to use the index and recognize key words, not memorizing the whole book, which is impossible.
Hope this helps. Feel free to ask anything else and I'll do my best to answer.
Thanks and good luck!
Assuming that I have understood your question, refer Figure 3.15 from the following:
If this is of interest, I found a lot of similar information in the following (albeit the Fifth Edition):
http://www.amazon.com/Electrical-Machines-Drives-Systems-Edition/dp/0131776916
Hey there. Second year EET here. I'm in my third semester right now and can confirm everything westdonkeykong has mentioned being true. I cannot stress that you really must love math and physics to take this course. Although most of it is not that difficult, you'll find yourself using your calculator everyday in nearly every class and will be tested constantly on circuit analysis and problem solving skills. The only text book I would recommend having is Electrical Machines Drives and Power Systems by Theodore Wildi . I heard you can get it from some obscure places for really cheap.
http://www.amazon.ca/Electrical-Machines-Drives-Systems-Edition/dp/0131776916
Anywho, make sure you start looking for your final project topic early, you'll likely end up changing it multiple times. So far only a few of my classmates have jobs but there isn't a lot of hiring going on until December and January. The big industry night is in January. It's one night where a bunch of employers come to Sait looking to hire and speak with EET's only, though there are plenty of other job fairs to seek employment.
Its a great program with amazing instructors and if you're really interested I think the next open house is in February sometime so keep your eye open for that!
Edit: Here is one job opportunity I'm seriously considering applying for right now:
https://www.bchydro.com/careers/students_grads/technologist.html
BC Hydro has been to sait this year recruiting for the four year technologist in training program. The way they explained it is, you are employed full time and you go on rotations once per year, so you may have to relocate every year doing something different at a different location. There is also some additional schooling and training. At the end of the four year program you will have a well rounded knowledge of multiple disciplines and have employment in one of their many locations.
I probably didn't do the best at explaining that but I'm sure if you're interested enough you'll find out on your own.
Popular alternatives to Electrical Machines, Drives...
