What is Reddit's opinion of Fireproof Document Bag,ENGPOW Fireproof Water Resistant Pouch with Handle Zipper, Non-Itchy Silicone Coated Fiberglass Envelope, Fire-Resistant Safe Storage of Valuables?

From 3.5 billion Reddit comments

> The bags don't provide insulation, they only keep the O2 out so the paper can't burn.

i don't think a zipper or velcro enclosure is enough to keep oxygen out of anything.

​

>Sadly that video didn't check the temperature of the fire. These bags and safes have specific temperature and duration requirements so if the fire was hotter than that then of course they failed.

it was an unaccelerated wood fire, for a claimed 15 minutes.

wood fires top out at about 600c, and i wouldn't consider 15 minutes to be an unreasonable duration. after all, the presumption is that the bag survives a house burning down around it.

the manufacturer claims the following :

> Made of high quality Silicone Coated Retardant-fiberglass exterior and aluminum foil interior, which c*an withstand temperatures as high as 1000°C* (about 1832°F), so you can keep all your valuables 100% safe.
>
>https://www.amazon.com/Fireproof-ENGPOW-Resistant-Fiberglass-Fire-Resistant/dp/B076SVJPHZ