It might ruin the surprise, but you could try this one- it comes in 15.5-16. (Silicone has give to it so it might work…and for $9 is an easy way to try! Bonus that it’s returnable if it doesn’t work.)
Popular alternatives to
Men's Silicone Ring, Step E...
Double Accent 8MM Stainless Steel Black Anodized Card Ace Wedding Band (Size 8 to 13), 9