RedditFavorites

Reddit's favorite alternatives to NHL Philadelphia Flyers Stick Toy for Dogs & Cats. Play Hockey with Your Pet with This Licensed Dog Tough Toy Reward!

From 3.5 billion Reddit comments

Alternatives

PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats, Blue

PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats, Blue

Popularity score: 64
< $25
Cat Dancer 101 Cat Dancer Interactive Cat Toy

Cat Dancer 101 Cat Dancer Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 61
< $25
GoCat Da Bird Pull 2 Piece Pull Apart Rod & Bird, Handmade in The USA (1 Bird)

GoCat Da Bird Pull 2 Piece Pull Apart Rod & Bird, Handmade in The USA (1 Bird)

Popularity score: 37
< $50
Petstages Tower of Tracks Interactive 3-Tier Cat Toy

Petstages Tower of Tracks Interactive 3-Tier Cat Toy

Popularity score: 25
< $25
Outback Jack Kitty Compound, Play House and Outdoor Cat Enclosures for Indoor Cats (Portable Cat Tent, Cat Tunnel, Cat Kennel and Playhouse) Play Tents for Cats and Small Animals

Outback Jack Kitty Compound, Play House and Outdoor Cat Enclosures for Indoor Cats (Portable Cat Tent, Cat Tunnel, Cat Kennel and Playhouse) Play Tents for Cats and Small Animals

Popularity score: 22
$50 - $100
PetSafe Bolt - Laser Pointer Cat Toy / Dog Toy - Automatic Cat Laser Toy: Manual & Random Pattern Mode, Cat Anxiety Relief, Hands Free, Auto Shutoff, Battery Operated, Laser Safe - Interactive Cat Toy

PetSafe Bolt - Laser Pointer Cat Toy / Dog Toy - Automatic Cat Laser Toy: Manual & Random Pattern Mode, Cat Anxiety Relief, Hands Free, Auto Shutoff, Battery Operated, Laser Safe - Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 20
< $50
SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy, Blue

SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy, Blue

Popularity score: 20
< $50
SPOT Ethical Products Ethical Wide Colorful Springs Cat Toy

SPOT Ethical Products Ethical Wide Colorful Springs Cat Toy

Popularity score: 19
< $25
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana

Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana

Popularity score: 18
< $25
Catit Senses 2.0 Digger Interactive Cat Toy

Catit Senses 2.0 Digger Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 18
< $50
Cat Dancer Products Rainbow Cat Charmer

Cat Dancer Products Rainbow Cat Charmer

Popularity score: 17
< $25
Catit Design Senses Play Circuit, Original

Catit Design Senses Play Circuit, Original

Popularity score: 16
< $50
Pop N’ Play Interactive Motion Cat Toy, Includes: Electronic Smart Random Moving Feather & Mouse Teaser, Mouse Squeak Sound Optional & Auto Shut Off. Best Cat Toy Ever!

Pop N’ Play Interactive Motion Cat Toy, Includes: Electronic Smart Random Moving Feather & Mouse Teaser, Mouse Squeak Sound Optional & Auto Shut Off. Best Cat Toy Ever!

Popularity score: 16
< $50
Trixie Activity Fun Board

Trixie Activity Fun Board

Popularity score: 16
< $50
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice, 3/pkg, Gray, Beige (39384)

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice, 3/pkg, Gray, Beige (39384)

Popularity score: 14
< $25
GoCat Da Bird Rod and Feather Cat Toy, Handmade in The USA (1 Bird)

GoCat Da Bird Rod and Feather Cat Toy, Handmade in The USA (1 Bird)

Popularity score: 14
< $50
MeoHui Interactive Cat Feather Toys, 2PCS Retractable Cat Wand Toy and 9PCS Squiggly Worm Feathers Teaser Refills, Cat Toys for Indoor Cats Kitten Play Chase Exercise

MeoHui Interactive Cat Feather Toys, 2PCS Retractable Cat Wand Toy and 9PCS Squiggly Worm Feathers Teaser Refills, Cat Toys for Indoor Cats Kitten Play Chase Exercise

Popularity score: 13
< $50
Go Cat Cat Catcher Teaser Wand with Mouse Cat Toy

Go Cat Cat Catcher Teaser Wand with Mouse Cat Toy

Popularity score: 13
< $50
Doc & Phoebe's Indoor Hunting Cat Feeder

Doc & Phoebe's Indoor Hunting Cat Feeder

Popularity score: 12
< $50
Cat's Meow- Motorized Wand Cat Toy, Automatic 30 Minute Shut Off, 3 Speed Settings, The Toy Your Cat Can't Resist

Cat's Meow- Motorized Wand Cat Toy, Automatic 30 Minute Shut Off, 3 Speed Settings, The Toy Your Cat Can't Resist

Popularity score: 12
< $50
smartpetlove - Snuggle Kitty - Behavioral Aid Toy for Pets - Tan Tiger

smartpetlove - Snuggle Kitty - Behavioral Aid Toy for Pets - Tan Tiger

Popularity score: 11
< $50
Petstages Purr Pillow Kitty Soothing Plush Cat Toy

Petstages Purr Pillow Kitty Soothing Plush Cat Toy

Popularity score: 11
< $50
Outback Jack Happy Habitat Portable Cat Tent

Outback Jack Happy Habitat Portable Cat Tent

Popularity score: 10
$50 - $100
Moody Pet Fling-AMA-String Cat Toy

Moody Pet Fling-AMA-String Cat Toy

Popularity score: 9
< $50
Catit Design Senses Super Roller Circuit Toy for Cats

Catit Design Senses Super Roller Circuit Toy for Cats

Popularity score: 9
< $50
Catit Treat Ball, Blue

Catit Treat Ball, Blue

Popularity score: 9
< $50
YVE LIFE Cat Laser Toy Automatic,Interactive Toy for Kitten/Dogs - USB Charging,Placing High,5 Random Pattern,Automatic On/Off and Silent (P01)

YVE LIFE Cat Laser Toy Automatic,Interactive Toy for Kitten/Dogs - USB Charging,Placing High,5 Random Pattern,Automatic On/Off and Silent (P01)

Popularity score: 8
Cat Dancer Cat Toy Cat Charmer Safe Wand Teaser Colorful Fabric Ribbon Safe Flexible Exercise Toy 1 Pack

Cat Dancer Cat Toy Cat Charmer Safe Wand Teaser Colorful Fabric Ribbon Safe Flexible Exercise Toy 1 Pack

Popularity score: 8
< $25
Da Bird Single 3 Foot Pole Cat Toy with 2 Extra Guinea Feather Refills

Da Bird Single 3 Foot Pole Cat Toy with 2 Extra Guinea Feather Refills

Popularity score: 8
< $50
Flurff Cat Toys, Interactive Cat Toy Butterfly Funny Exercise Electric Flutter Rotating Kitten Toys, Cat Teaser with Replacement

Flurff Cat Toys, Interactive Cat Toy Butterfly Funny Exercise Electric Flutter Rotating Kitten Toys, Cat Teaser with Replacement

Popularity score: 8
< $50
Indoor Cat Interactive Swimming Fish Toy- Best Water Cat Toy for Indoor Cats, Play Fishing, Good Exercise, Drink More Water, led Light, Battery Included (Swimming Bowl is not Included) (4 Pcs)

Indoor Cat Interactive Swimming Fish Toy- Best Water Cat Toy for Indoor Cats, Play Fishing, Good Exercise, Drink More Water, led Light, Battery Included (Swimming Bowl is not Included) (4 Pcs)

Popularity score: 8
< $50
SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy

SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy

Popularity score: 8
Potaroma Electric Flopping Fish 10.5", Moving Cat Kicker Fish Toy, Floppy Fish Toy for Small Dogs Wiggle Fish Catnip Toys, Motion Kitten Toy Plush Interactive Cat Toys for Exercise, Mice Animal Toys

Potaroma Electric Flopping Fish 10.5", Moving Cat Kicker Fish Toy, Floppy Fish Toy for Small Dogs Wiggle Fish Catnip Toys, Motion Kitten Toy Plush Interactive Cat Toys for Exercise, Mice Animal Toys

Popularity score: 7
< $50
Catit Design Senses Food Maze_DX

Catit Design Senses Food Maze_DX

Popularity score: 7
< $50
Killer's Instinct Outdoors Cat Funny Toys Interactive Wooden Solid Whack A Mole Mouse Game Puzzle Toy

Killer's Instinct Outdoors Cat Funny Toys Interactive Wooden Solid Whack A Mole Mouse Game Puzzle Toy

Popularity score: 7
< $50
Petlinks Mystery Motion Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy, Colors may vary (094208)

Petlinks Mystery Motion Cat Toy Concealed Motion Toy, Colors may vary (094208)

Popularity score: 7
< $50
Ethical A-Door-Able Bouncing Mouse Cat Toy , Assorted Colors

Ethical A-Door-Able Bouncing Mouse Cat Toy , Assorted Colors

Popularity score: 6
< $25
Cat Toys - Cat Teaser Toys - Include Cat Wand and Natural Feather Refills (5 Pack)

Cat Toys - Cat Teaser Toys - Include Cat Wand and Natural Feather Refills (5 Pack)

Popularity score: 6
< $25
PETFAVORITES Original Mylar Crinkle Balls Cat Toys - 12 Pack

PETFAVORITES Original Mylar Crinkle Balls Cat Toys - 12 Pack

Popularity score: 5
< $25
TOOGE 2 Pack 11" Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy Realistic Interactive Flopping Fish Cat Kicker Catnip Toys for Indoor Cats Pets Kitten (Black)

TOOGE 2 Pack 11" Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy Realistic Interactive Flopping Fish Cat Kicker Catnip Toys for Indoor Cats Pets Kitten (Black)

Popularity score: 5
< $50
Petz Route Long Stick Play with a Kitten Made in Japan

Petz Route Long Stick Play with a Kitten Made in Japan

Popularity score: 5
< $25
CAT DANCER Deluxe 252 Cat Toy

CAT DANCER Deluxe 252 Cat Toy

Popularity score: 5
< $25
Kitty City Large Cat Tunnel Bed, Cat Bed, Pop Up bed, Cat Toys, Christmas Tree

Kitty City Large Cat Tunnel Bed, Cat Bed, Pop Up bed, Cat Toys, Christmas Tree

Popularity score: 5
< $50
PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

Popularity score: 5
< $25
CAT AMAZING – Best Cat Toy Ever! Interactive Treat Maze & Puzzle Feeder for Cats

CAT AMAZING – Best Cat Toy Ever! Interactive Treat Maze & Puzzle Feeder for Cats

Popularity score: 5
< $50
GoCat Cat Catcher Da Bee Cat Toy, Handmade in The USA (1 Bee)

GoCat Cat Catcher Da Bee Cat Toy, Handmade in The USA (1 Bee)

Popularity score: 5
< $50
Youngever 24 Cat Toys Kitten Toys Assortments, 2 Way Tunnel, Cat Feather Teaser - Wand Interactive Feather Toy Fluffy Mouse, Crinkle Balls for Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten

Youngever 24 Cat Toys Kitten Toys Assortments, 2 Way Tunnel, Cat Feather Teaser - Wand Interactive Feather Toy Fluffy Mouse, Crinkle Balls for Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten

Popularity score: 5
< $50
Arm & Hammer for Pets Super Treadz Gorilla Dental Chew Toy for Dogs - Dog Dental Chew Toys Reduce Plaque & Tartar Buildup Without Brushing - Safe for Dogs up to 35 Lbs

Arm & Hammer for Pets Super Treadz Gorilla Dental Chew Toy for Dogs - Dog Dental Chew Toys Reduce Plaque & Tartar Buildup Without Brushing - Safe for Dogs up to 35 Lbs

Popularity score: 5
< $25
PetSafe Pounce Cat Toy, Interactive Automatic Toy for Cat or Kitten, Adjustable Electronic Battery Operated Toy

PetSafe Pounce Cat Toy, Interactive Automatic Toy for Cat or Kitten, Adjustable Electronic Battery Operated Toy

Popularity score: 4
Cosmic OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Chili Cat Toy-Hot Stuff (Interactive Cat Toy, Catnip Toys for Cats, Cat Chew Toy, Catnip Toys)

Cosmic OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Chili Cat Toy-Hot Stuff (Interactive Cat Toy, Catnip Toys for Cats, Cat Chew Toy, Catnip Toys)

Popularity score: 4
< $25
All for Paws Interactive Flutter Bug Cat Butterfly Toy with Two Replacements Kitten Toys for Indoor Cats

All for Paws Interactive Flutter Bug Cat Butterfly Toy with Two Replacements Kitten Toys for Indoor Cats

Popularity score: 4
< $50
SmartyKat Feather Whirl Electronic Motion Cat Toy, As Seen On TV (9621), green

SmartyKat Feather Whirl Electronic Motion Cat Toy, As Seen On TV (9621), green

Popularity score: 4
< $50
FYNIGO Cat Toys for Indoor Cats,Interactive Cat Feather Toy,Retractable Cat Teaser Wand Toy with 8 Refills and a Spare Hook

FYNIGO Cat Toys for Indoor Cats,Interactive Cat Feather Toy,Retractable Cat Teaser Wand Toy with 8 Refills and a Spare Hook

Popularity score: 4
< $25
Fashion's Talk Cat Toys Variety Pack for Kitty 20 Pieces

Fashion's Talk Cat Toys Variety Pack for Kitty 20 Pieces

Popularity score: 4
< $50
Petlinks Tea Zing Cat Toy Catnip Tea Bag Toys, 3 Pack

Petlinks Tea Zing Cat Toy Catnip Tea Bag Toys, 3 Pack

Popularity score: 4
< $25
Beewarm Floppy Fish Dog Toy Flopping Fish Cat Toys for Indoor Cats Catnip Toys for Cats Dogs (Catfish)

Beewarm Floppy Fish Dog Toy Flopping Fish Cat Toys for Indoor Cats Catnip Toys for Cats Dogs (Catfish)

Popularity score: 4
< $50
Catit Senses 2.0, Play Circuit, Interactive Cat Toy

Catit Senses 2.0, Play Circuit, Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 4
< $50
Purrfect Arch Deluxe Self Grooming and Massaging Cat Toy- Arch Brush Helps Reduce Shedding & Scratching To Keep Your Home Fur Free, Grey (PR011106)

Purrfect Arch Deluxe Self Grooming and Massaging Cat Toy- Arch Brush Helps Reduce Shedding & Scratching To Keep Your Home Fur Free, Grey (PR011106)

Popularity score: 4
Senneny 2 Pack Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy, Realistic Plush Simulation Electric Wagging Fish Cat Toy Catnip Kicker Toys, Funny Interactive Pets Pillow Chew Bite Kick Supplies for Cat Kitten Kitty

Senneny 2 Pack Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy, Realistic Plush Simulation Electric Wagging Fish Cat Toy Catnip Kicker Toys, Funny Interactive Pets Pillow Chew Bite Kick Supplies for Cat Kitten Kitty

Popularity score: 4
< $50
FATCAT Crazy Circle Interactive Cat Toy

FATCAT Crazy Circle Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 4
< $25
Kookamunga Krazee Kitty Catnip Bubbles, 5 oz

Kookamunga Krazee Kitty Catnip Bubbles, 5 oz

Popularity score: 4
< $25
Bestsupplier 25 Pack Crinkle Balls Cat Toys - Original Mylar Crinkle Balls Cat Toys(Random Color)

Bestsupplier 25 Pack Crinkle Balls Cat Toys - Original Mylar Crinkle Balls Cat Toys(Random Color)

Popularity score: 4
< $25
OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Carrot Cat Toy 24 Karat

OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Carrot Cat Toy 24 Karat

Popularity score: 4
< $25
UPSKY Cat Toy Roller 3-Level Turntable Cat Toys Balls with Six Colorful Balls Interactive Kitten Fun Mental Physical Exercise Puzzle Kitten Toys.

UPSKY Cat Toy Roller 3-Level Turntable Cat Toys Balls with Six Colorful Balls Interactive Kitten Fun Mental Physical Exercise Puzzle Kitten Toys.

Popularity score: 4
< $25
baotongle 70 PCS Assorted Color Sparkle Balls, Tinsel Pom Poms Glitter for Cat Kittens

baotongle 70 PCS Assorted Color Sparkle Balls, Tinsel Pom Poms Glitter for Cat Kittens

Popularity score: 4
< $50
SmartyKat Loco Motion, Electronic Motion Cat Toy, Interactive Wand with Feathers, Adjustable Speed, Battery Powered

SmartyKat Loco Motion, Electronic Motion Cat Toy, Interactive Wand with Feathers, Adjustable Speed, Battery Powered

Popularity score: 4
< $50
none-branded Cat Massage Roller Relaxer Face Massager for Kitty Pet Toy(Blue)

none-branded Cat Massage Roller Relaxer Face Massager for Kitty Pet Toy(Blue)

Popularity score: 4
Petstages Dental Kitty Chew Wheel Catnip Cat Toy

Petstages Dental Kitty Chew Wheel Catnip Cat Toy

Popularity score: 4
< $25
PetSafe FroliCat Pounce Rotating Cat Teaser

PetSafe FroliCat Pounce Rotating Cat Teaser

Popularity score: 4
Catit Self Groomer with Catnip

Catit Self Groomer with Catnip

Popularity score: 4
< $25
Hartz Cattraction Bell Mouse Cat Toy with Two Silver Vine & Catnip Sisal Mice

Hartz Cattraction Bell Mouse Cat Toy with Two Silver Vine & Catnip Sisal Mice

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Andiker Cat Spiral Spring, 12 Pc Cat Creative Toy to Kill Time and Keep Fit Interactive cat Toy Durable Heavy Plastic Spring Colorful Springs Cat Toy for Swatting, Biting, Hunting Kitten Toys

Andiker Cat Spiral Spring, 12 Pc Cat Creative Toy to Kill Time and Keep Fit Interactive cat Toy Durable Heavy Plastic Spring Colorful Springs Cat Toy for Swatting, Biting, Hunting Kitten Toys

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Pet Zone Fly By Spinner Butterfly Cat Toy,Lifelike Flying Movement & Realistic Fluttering Sound (Interactive Cat Toys,Kitten Toys, Cat Toys for Indoor Cats)[Great Alternative to Pop and Play Cat Toy]

Pet Zone Fly By Spinner Butterfly Cat Toy,Lifelike Flying Movement & Realistic Fluttering Sound (Interactive Cat Toys,Kitten Toys, Cat Toys for Indoor Cats)[Great Alternative to Pop and Play Cat Toy]

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Tamu style Cat Spring Toys (60 Pack), Playful Coils for Kittens, BPA Free Plastic for Swatting, Biting, Hunting, and Active Healthy Play, Colorful 2 Inch Spirals

Tamu style Cat Spring Toys (60 Pack), Playful Coils for Kittens, BPA Free Plastic for Swatting, Biting, Hunting, and Active Healthy Play, Colorful 2 Inch Spirals

Popularity score: 3
< $25
FAT CAT Crazy Circle Interactive Cat Toy

FAT CAT Crazy Circle Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 3
< $50
Rimobul 20PCS 1.5INCH New Generation Extra Large Cat's Favorite Chase Glitter Ball Toy Sparkle Pom Pom Balls

Rimobul 20PCS 1.5INCH New Generation Extra Large Cat's Favorite Chase Glitter Ball Toy Sparkle Pom Pom Balls

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Pet Fit For Life Multi Feather Teaser and Exerciser for Cat and Kitten - Cat Toy Interactive Cat Wand

Pet Fit For Life Multi Feather Teaser and Exerciser for Cat and Kitten - Cat Toy Interactive Cat Wand

Popularity score: 3
< $25
PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

Popularity score: 3
< $25
KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)

KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)

Popularity score: 3
< $25
CiyvoLyeen 6 Pack Sushi Cat Toys with Catnip Sushi Roll Pillow Kitten Chew Bite Supplies Boredom Relief Fluffy Kitty Teeth Cleaning Chewing Cat Lovers Interactive Plush Gift

CiyvoLyeen 6 Pack Sushi Cat Toys with Catnip Sushi Roll Pillow Kitten Chew Bite Supplies Boredom Relief Fluffy Kitty Teeth Cleaning Chewing Cat Lovers Interactive Plush Gift

Popularity score: 3
< $50
YEOWWW! DuckyWorld 100% ORGANIC CATNIP Leaf & Flower Cat Toy BANANA 3 PACK

YEOWWW! DuckyWorld 100% ORGANIC CATNIP Leaf & Flower Cat Toy BANANA 3 PACK

Popularity score: 3
< $50
HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys - 12 Pack

HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys - 12 Pack

Popularity score: 3
Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Worms Teaser and Exerciser for Cat and Kitten - Cat Toy Interactive Cat Wand

Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Worms Teaser and Exerciser for Cat and Kitten - Cat Toy Interactive Cat Wand

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Doskocil PETMATE 26317 Cat Crazies Cat Toy, Multi, one Size

Doskocil PETMATE 26317 Cat Crazies Cat Toy, Multi, one Size

Popularity score: 3
Kitty City Safari Play Cubee, Cat Cube, Play Kennel, Cat Bed, Jungle Cat House, Multicolor, 15 H x15 W inches

Kitty City Safari Play Cubee, Cat Cube, Play Kennel, Cat Bed, Jungle Cat House, Multicolor, 15 H x15 W inches

Popularity score: 3
< $25
MIBOTE 28Pcs Cat Toys Kitten Toys Assorted, Cat Tunnel Catnip Fish Feather Teaser Wand Fish Fluffy Mouse Mice Balls and Bells Toys for Cat Puppy Kitty

MIBOTE 28Pcs Cat Toys Kitten Toys Assorted, Cat Tunnel Catnip Fish Feather Teaser Wand Fish Fluffy Mouse Mice Balls and Bells Toys for Cat Puppy Kitty

Popularity score: 3
< $50
Kaytee Crinkle Tunnel, Colors Vary

Kaytee Crinkle Tunnel, Colors Vary

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Electric Floppy Fish Cat Toy, Moving Cat Kicker Fish Toy, 11" Realistic Flopping Fish Dog Toy, Plush Interactive Cat Toy for Indoor Cats, Wiggle Fish Catnip Toys

Electric Floppy Fish Cat Toy, Moving Cat Kicker Fish Toy, 11" Realistic Flopping Fish Dog Toy, Plush Interactive Cat Toy for Indoor Cats, Wiggle Fish Catnip Toys

Popularity score: 3
< $50
KONG - Kickeroo Giraffe Pattern - Play Enticing Cat Toy, North American Premium Catnip

KONG - Kickeroo Giraffe Pattern - Play Enticing Cat Toy, North American Premium Catnip

Popularity score: 3
< $50
Ethical Thin Colorful Springs Cat Toy, 10-Pack

Ethical Thin Colorful Springs Cat Toy, 10-Pack

Popularity score: 3
< $25
Catit Senses 2.0 Cat Grass Planter, Interactive Cat Toys

Catit Senses 2.0 Cat Grass Planter, Interactive Cat Toys

Popularity score: 3
< $50
KONG - Kickeroo Cuddler - Play Enticing Cat Toy, North American Premium Catnip (colors my vary)

KONG - Kickeroo Cuddler - Play Enticing Cat Toy, North American Premium Catnip (colors my vary)

Popularity score: 3
15PCS Natural Silvervine Sticks for Cats, Catnip Sticks Matatabi Chew Sticks Teeth Molar Chew Toys for Cat Kitten Kitty Teeth Cleaning

15PCS Natural Silvervine Sticks for Cats, Catnip Sticks Matatabi Chew Sticks Teeth Molar Chew Toys for Cat Kitten Kitty Teeth Cleaning

Popularity score: 3
< $25
SPOT Ethical Pet Catnip Cat or Kitten Toy, Colorful Fun Tubes. Interactive Bouncy cat Toy, Assorted Color

SPOT Ethical Pet Catnip Cat or Kitten Toy, Colorful Fun Tubes. Interactive Bouncy cat Toy, Assorted Color

Popularity score: 3
< $25
60 Pack Cat Spring Toy Plastic Colorful Coil Spiral Springs Pet Action Wide Durable Interactive Toys

60 Pack Cat Spring Toy Plastic Colorful Coil Spiral Springs Pet Action Wide Durable Interactive Toys

Popularity score: 2
< $25
OurPets Play-N-Treat Twin Pack Cat Toy

OurPets Play-N-Treat Twin Pack Cat Toy

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Tamu style Cat Spring Toys (30 Pack), Plastic Coils for Indoor Active Healthy Play, Colorful 2 Inch Spirals

Tamu style Cat Spring Toys (30 Pack), Plastic Coils for Indoor Active Healthy Play, Colorful 2 Inch Spirals

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Pawaboo Cat Toys, Cat Tunnel Tube 3-Way Tunnels 25x40cm Extensible Collapsible Cat Play Tent Interactive Toy Maze Cat House Bed with Balls and Bells for Cat Kitten Kitty Rabbit Small Animal, Blue

Pawaboo Cat Toys, Cat Tunnel Tube 3-Way Tunnels 25x40cm Extensible Collapsible Cat Play Tent Interactive Toy Maze Cat House Bed with Balls and Bells for Cat Kitten Kitty Rabbit Small Animal, Blue

Popularity score: 2
< $50
DELOMO Cat Light Toy, Smart Interactive Cat Toy, 2 Rotating Modes Automatic cat Toy, USB Rechargeable Light Dot Toy for Cat Chasing

DELOMO Cat Light Toy, Smart Interactive Cat Toy, 2 Rotating Modes Automatic cat Toy, USB Rechargeable Light Dot Toy for Cat Chasing

Popularity score: 2
< $50
KONG Kickeroo Pattern No.3 Catnip Toy, Colors Vary, Tiger

KONG Kickeroo Pattern No.3 Catnip Toy, Colors Vary, Tiger

Popularity score: 2
SmartyKat KnockOut Treat Dispensing Toy

SmartyKat KnockOut Treat Dispensing Toy

Popularity score: 2
Legendog Legendog Cat Slow Feeder Cat Food Ball Mice Water Droplet Bone Tumbler Shaped Pet Treat Ball Cat Food Toy Ball Pet Food Ball (White)

Legendog Legendog Cat Slow Feeder Cat Food Ball Mice Water Droplet Bone Tumbler Shaped Pet Treat Ball Cat Food Toy Ball Pet Food Ball (White)

Popularity score: 2
< $25
TRIXIE Pet Products Tunnel Self Feeder for Cats

TRIXIE Pet Products Tunnel Self Feeder for Cats

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Meowy Janes Matatabi Chew Sticks - An All Natural Silvervine Cat Toy and Cat Treat - Catnip Alternative

Meowy Janes Matatabi Chew Sticks - An All Natural Silvervine Cat Toy and Cat Treat - Catnip Alternative

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Qaxlry Play Fur Mice Cat Toys – Mixed Bag of 10 Play Mice with Rattling Sounds – 4 Color Variety Pack of Catnip Toy

Qaxlry Play Fur Mice Cat Toys – Mixed Bag of 10 Play Mice with Rattling Sounds – 4 Color Variety Pack of Catnip Toy

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Petstages Night Time Catnip Rolls

Petstages Night Time Catnip Rolls

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Cat Toy Orca Wiggle Worm 4"

Cat Toy Orca Wiggle Worm 4"

Popularity score: 2
< $25
OurPets Three Twined Mice Cat Toys, 3 pc

OurPets Three Twined Mice Cat Toys, 3 pc

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Bergan Turbo Track Cat Toy

Bergan Turbo Track Cat Toy

Popularity score: 2
Vitakraft Purrk Playfuls Silvervine Powder Packets with Toy Mouse, .5 grams, 5 Pack

Vitakraft Purrk Playfuls Silvervine Powder Packets with Toy Mouse, .5 grams, 5 Pack

Popularity score: 2
Petmate Jackson Galaxy Satellites Cat Toy Multi, One Size

Petmate Jackson Galaxy Satellites Cat Toy Multi, One Size

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Catit Play Circuit Ball Cat Toy with Scratch Pad, Catnip Toy, Blue, 43001

Catit Play Circuit Ball Cat Toy with Scratch Pad, Catnip Toy, Blue, 43001

Popularity score: 2
WoLover Silvervine Sticks for Cats, Natural Catnip Sticks Matatabi Chew Sticks Teeth Molar Chew Toys for Cat Kitten Kitty (at Least 12 PCS)

WoLover Silvervine Sticks for Cats, Natural Catnip Sticks Matatabi Chew Sticks Teeth Molar Chew Toys for Cat Kitten Kitty (at Least 12 PCS)

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Ethical Skinneeez Forest Friends Wand Cat Toy

Ethical Skinneeez Forest Friends Wand Cat Toy

Popularity score: 2
< $25
goDog Furballz Rainbow Plush Dog Toy with Chew Guard Technology, Large, Rainbow

goDog Furballz Rainbow Plush Dog Toy with Chew Guard Technology, Large, Rainbow

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Friskies Wobbert Cat Toy Play Pack (Pull 'n Play line)

Friskies Wobbert Cat Toy Play Pack (Pull 'n Play line)

Popularity score: 2
OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Banana Cat Toy A Peeling

OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Banana Cat Toy A Peeling

Popularity score: 2
< $25
GDPet 10 Piece Including Cat Teaser Wand Interactive Feather Toy Fluffy Mouse Mylar Crinkle Balls Catnip Pillow for Kitten/Kitty

GDPet 10 Piece Including Cat Teaser Wand Interactive Feather Toy Fluffy Mouse Mylar Crinkle Balls Catnip Pillow for Kitten/Kitty

Popularity score: 2
Skinneeez Duck Cat Toy, 3" Assorted Sold Individually

Skinneeez Duck Cat Toy, 3" Assorted Sold Individually

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Petlinks System Refillable Catnip Cat Toys, Tan (49370)

Petlinks System Refillable Catnip Cat Toys, Tan (49370)

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Real Rabbit Fur Pom Pom Cat Toy - 5 Pak

Real Rabbit Fur Pom Pom Cat Toy - 5 Pak

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Cat Amazing Sliders – Interactive Treat Puzzle Cat Toy – Active Food Puzzle Feeder

Cat Amazing Sliders – Interactive Treat Puzzle Cat Toy – Active Food Puzzle Feeder

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Chiwava 36PCS 4.1'' Furry Cat Toy Mice Rattle Small Mouse Kitten Interactive Play Assorted Color

Chiwava 36PCS 4.1'' Furry Cat Toy Mice Rattle Small Mouse Kitten Interactive Play Assorted Color

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Cat Toys - Funny Automatic Electric Rotating Butterfly & Ball Exercise Kitten Toy,Interactive Cat Teaser Toys for Indoor Cats (air Blue)

Cat Toys - Funny Automatic Electric Rotating Butterfly & Ball Exercise Kitten Toy,Interactive Cat Teaser Toys for Indoor Cats (air Blue)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Dog Puzzle Teething Toys Ball Nontoxic Durable Dog IQ Chew Toys for Puppy Small Large Dog Teeth Cleaning/Chewing/Playing/Treat Dispensing Dog Toys (2 Pack)

Dog Puzzle Teething Toys Ball Nontoxic Durable Dog IQ Chew Toys for Puppy Small Large Dog Teeth Cleaning/Chewing/Playing/Treat Dispensing Dog Toys (2 Pack)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Cat Dancer 022CD01-101 Cat Dancer Original Toy

Cat Dancer 022CD01-101 Cat Dancer Original Toy

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Replacement Pack of Worms for Interactive Cat and Kitten Toy Wands

Pet Fit For Life 5 Piece Replacement Pack of Worms for Interactive Cat and Kitten Toy Wands

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Outback Jack Fun Run Cat Tunnel

Outback Jack Fun Run Cat Tunnel

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Petstages Fresh Breath Mint Stick

Petstages Fresh Breath Mint Stick

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Comfy Pet Supplies Set of 6-100% Wool Felt Ball Toys for Cats and Kittens, Handmade Colorful Eco-Friendly Cat Wool Balls (4cm, Gray Mint Blue Red Pink Yellow)

Comfy Pet Supplies Set of 6-100% Wool Felt Ball Toys for Cats and Kittens, Handmade Colorful Eco-Friendly Cat Wool Balls (4cm, Gray Mint Blue Red Pink Yellow)

Popularity score: 2
Cancor Innovations Mini Crinkle Ball Cat Toy (50 Pack)

Cancor Innovations Mini Crinkle Ball Cat Toy (50 Pack)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Cat Toy - Cat Powered Mouse Chaser - With Scratch Pad - Assorted colors

Cat Toy - Cat Powered Mouse Chaser - With Scratch Pad - Assorted colors

Popularity score: 2
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Rainbow

Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Rainbow

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Youngever 7 Cat Toys Assortment with 5 Refillable Catnip Fish Cat Toys and 2 Catnip Fur Mouse Cat Toys, Extra Catnip for Refill, for Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten, Ferret, Rabbit

Youngever 7 Cat Toys Assortment with 5 Refillable Catnip Fish Cat Toys and 2 Catnip Fur Mouse Cat Toys, Extra Catnip for Refill, for Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten, Ferret, Rabbit

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Speedy Pet Collapsible Cat Tunnel, Cat Toys Play Tunnel Durable Suede Hideaway Pet Crinkle Tunnel with Ball M

Speedy Pet Collapsible Cat Tunnel, Cat Toys Play Tunnel Durable Suede Hideaway Pet Crinkle Tunnel with Ball M

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Catit Play Cat Treat Puzzle, Interactive Cat Toy, 43010, White

Catit Play Cat Treat Puzzle, Interactive Cat Toy, 43010, White

Popularity score: 2
< $50
KONG - Cat Wubba Hugga - Fleece Plush Catnip Toy (Assorted Colors)

KONG - Cat Wubba Hugga - Fleece Plush Catnip Toy (Assorted Colors)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

PetSafe SlimCat Meal-Dispensing Cat Toy, Great for Food or Treats

Popularity score: 2
< $25
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack (Set of 10) Soft Plush Catnip Cat Toys, Mice Toys with String Tails, Filled with Pure & Potent Catnip

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack (Set of 10) Soft Plush Catnip Cat Toys, Mice Toys with String Tails, Filled with Pure & Potent Catnip

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Senneny Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy, Realistic Plush Simulation Electric Wagging Fish Cat Toy Catnip Kicker Toys, Funny Interactive Pets Pillow Chew Bite Kick Supplies for Cat Kitten Kitty (Catfish)

Senneny Electric Moving Fish Cat Toy, Realistic Plush Simulation Electric Wagging Fish Cat Toy Catnip Kicker Toys, Funny Interactive Pets Pillow Chew Bite Kick Supplies for Cat Kitten Kitty (Catfish)

Popularity score: 2
< $25
PetSafe Automatic Cheese Cat Toy, Interactive Electronic Mouse Hunt, Durable Toy with Multiple Play Modes, Fun for Kittens to Pounce and Play, White/Yellow, 5" x 5.75" x 7.5" (536161)

PetSafe Automatic Cheese Cat Toy, Interactive Electronic Mouse Hunt, Durable Toy with Multiple Play Modes, Fun for Kittens to Pounce and Play, White/Yellow, 5" x 5.75" x 7.5" (536161)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
CO-Z Collapsible Cat Tunnel Tube Kitty Tunnel Bored Cat Pet Toys Peek Hole Toy Ball Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten, Rabbit (3 Way)

CO-Z Collapsible Cat Tunnel Tube Kitty Tunnel Bored Cat Pet Toys Peek Hole Toy Ball Cat, Puppy, Kitty, Kitten, Rabbit (3 Way)

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Prosper Pet Cat Tunnel - Collapsible 3 Way Play Toy - Interactive Tube Toys for Rabbits, Kittens, and Dogs - Black/Pink

Prosper Pet Cat Tunnel - Collapsible 3 Way Play Toy - Interactive Tube Toys for Rabbits, Kittens, and Dogs - Black/Pink

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Catit Cat Toys Cat Grass Seeds (Set of 3)

Catit Cat Toys Cat Grass Seeds (Set of 3)

Popularity score: 2
< $25
KONG - Goodie Bone - Durable Rubber Chew Bone, Treat Dispensing Dog Toy - for Large Dogs

KONG - Goodie Bone - Durable Rubber Chew Bone, Treat Dispensing Dog Toy - for Large Dogs

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Ark Naturals Brushless Toothpaste, Dog Dental Chews for Small Breeds, Vet Recommended for Plaque, Bacteria & Tartar Control, 1 Count, Packaging May Vary

Ark Naturals Brushless Toothpaste, Dog Dental Chews for Small Breeds, Vet Recommended for Plaque, Bacteria & Tartar Control, 1 Count, Packaging May Vary

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Catit Senses 2.0, Super Circuit, Interactive Cat Toy

Catit Senses 2.0, Super Circuit, Interactive Cat Toy

Popularity score: 2
< $50
Sparkle Ball Cat Toys - 10 Pack - 1"

Sparkle Ball Cat Toys - 10 Pack - 1"

Popularity score: 2
< $25
OurPets Play-N-Squeak Real Birds Fly Over Interactive Cat Toy, Model:1010011957

OurPets Play-N-Squeak Real Birds Fly Over Interactive Cat Toy, Model:1010011957

Popularity score: 2
< $25
Ethical Colorful Springs (Pack of 2)

Ethical Colorful Springs (Pack of 2)

Popularity score: 2
< $25

Top Reddit reviews mentioning alternatives to NHL Philadelphia Flyers Stick Toy for Dogs & Cats. Play Hockey with Your Pet with This Licensed Dog Tough Toy Reward!:

56 points
·
18th Jan 2018
29 points
·
4th Aug 2021
19 points
·
26th Feb 2021
12 points
·
8th Jul 2019
12 points
·
28th Jan 2018
11 points
·
26th Apr 2019
6 points
·
28th Sep 2018
5 points
·
21st May 2021
5 points
·
24th Feb 2021
4 points
·
14th Feb 2021
4 points
·
18th Jan 2021
3 points
·
20th Sep 2021
3 points
·
7th Jul 2021
3 points
·
23rd Jun 2021
3 points
·
29th Jan 2021
3 points
·
24th Jan 2021
3 points
·
28th Nov 2020
3 points
·
16th Nov 2018
3 points
·
20th Dec 2018
3 points
·
4th Sep 2020
3 points
·
12th Aug 2020
2 points
·
29th Jun 2021
2 points
·
1st Jun 2021
2 points
·
11th May 2021
2 points
·
19th Apr 2021
2 points
·
19th Jan 2021
2 points
·
16th Jan 2021
2 points
·
12th Jan 2021
2 points
·
10th Dec 2020
2 points
·
19th Nov 2020
2 points
·
4th Nov 2020
2 points
·
15th Jun 2017
2 points
·
3rd Feb 2018
2 points
·
25th Aug 2020
2 points
·
7th Aug 2020
2 points
·
25th Jul 2020
2 points
·
18th Jul 2020
2 points
·
14th Jul 2020
2 points
·
14th Jul 2020
2 points
·
20th Sep 2020
2 points
·
21st May 2020
2 points
·
26th Sep 2015
2 points
·
14th Jun 2015
2 points
·
21st May 2015
2 points
·
10th Apr 2015
2 points
·
25th Feb 2015
1 point
·
19th Jan 2022
1 point
·
29th Dec 2021
1 point
·
28th Dec 2021
1 point
·
28th Dec 2021
1 point
·
27th Dec 2021
1 point
·
18th Dec 2021
1 point
·
18th Dec 2021
1 point
·
18th Dec 2021
1 point
·
8th Dec 2021
1 point
·
7th Dec 2021
1 point
·
4th Dec 2021
1 point
·
16th Nov 2021
1 point
·
16th Nov 2021
1 point
·
3rd Nov 2021
1 point
·
2nd Nov 2021
1 point
·
25th Oct 2021
1 point
·
25th Oct 2021
1 point
·
16th Oct 2021
1 point
·
16th Oct 2021
1 point
·
5th Oct 2021
1 point
·
2nd Oct 2021
1 point
·
29th Sep 2021
1 point
·
29th Sep 2021
1 point
·
28th Sep 2021
1 point
·
21st Sep 2021
1 point
·
20th Sep 2021
1 point
·
18th Sep 2021
1 point
·
7th Sep 2021
1 point
·
29th Aug 2021
1 point
·
28th Aug 2021
1 point
·
28th Aug 2021
1 point
·
28th Aug 2021
1 point
·
24th Aug 2021
1 point
·
23rd Aug 2021
1 point
·
2nd Aug 2021
1 point
·
2nd Aug 2021
1 point
·
14th Jun 2021
1 point
·
12th Jun 2021
1 point
·
9th Jun 2021
1 point
·
2nd Jun 2021
1 point
·
2nd Jun 2021
1 point
·
16th May 2021
1 point
·
10th May 2021
1 point
·
26th Apr 2021
1 point
·
22nd Apr 2021
1 point
·
7th Apr 2021
1 point
·
2nd Apr 2021
1 point
·
2nd Apr 2021