Polare's wallets are superb in my opinion. It's real cow leather and comes in black or brown. I've had the brown one for about 2-3 years now and it still looks amazing. It does, however, smooth out & darken over time, but I actually prefer that. They are also CHEAP!
Reviews are pretty split across the board. I personally have this wallet; the small is still kinda big, but it seems tough. I'd say if you buy the TH, make sure it's being sold directly by Amazon, not a third party. Good luck.
I've had this horse leather wallet for about a year now and its been amazing. SUPER durable and has lots of space for loose change and cards. Only down side is that it is rather large (especially before the leather is broken in). http://www.amazon.com/Polare-Cowboy-Genuine-Natural-Leather/dp/B013OS6BL6/
This one.