Is this the part you used? Seems fine, though I would prefer OEM. Thanks for the tip, I saw the two screws connecting the rubber but all the other older gens seem to require you going through the back of the hatch to fix it, this seems way easier. Plus I need a 90 degree screwdriver anyways...
IE Works Rear Hatch Button w/... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01BMMXOMU?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
There are some other kits on Amazon that come with right angle screw driver and some with scrapers. Depending on what you have on hand those might be worth looking at.
https://www.amazon.com/Button-Liftgate-4runner-Release-Replacement/dp/B01BMMXOMU
10 bucks + whatever time it takes you to replace it, if your not inclined to do it yourself buy it and take it to a shop shouldn't take them more than 20 min to install so labor will be cheap.