What is Reddit's opinion of Redbarn 4lb Beef Roll for Dogs (1-Count)?

From 3.5 billion Reddit comments

I really like the Red Barn Dog Food Roll. You cut it into the size pieces you want, they're soft but not mushy and hold their shape really well. Much more bang for your buck, decent ingredients, and are nice smelly high value treats. My dog is very fickle about taking food, especially outside or in a stressful environment, but this usually does the trick.

Got a new dog in a similar situation to you as last year and had many of the same questions. Here's my thoughts:

1. Probably no dog walker. However getting them used to one every once and a while is good in case something comes up.
2. Probably not lots of time off, however if you could take a morning or afternoon off for the first day or two that might help them adjust to extended leaves. Depends much on the dog.
3. We found professional help was very good -- more for training us than the dog. Group classes (if your dog is affable) are a good option both financially and socializing your pup.
4. It's a lot of work. But worth it. Give yourself a break sometimes. You sound like you're already mature enough to handle this well.

• We use a super-premium dog food as treats. It's called Redbarn beef roll -- we cut it into small cubes as training treats. It's great because he can have as many treats as he wants without worrying. On 4lb roll lasts us a good while.
• Chew toys depend a lot on the dog. Ours likes squeeky things. He also gets Bully Sticks -- expensive but when you read about some of the things in other dog chews (like pigs ears) you can decide if it is worth the trade off for you.
• Wire crate for sure -- way easier to transport when necessary.

Dog food rolls, easily one of my dogs highest value treats and stupidly cheap. We get the chicken liver kind off amazon and a 4 lb roll is probably like 2,000 ish pencil eraser sized treats. My trainer recommends them since they are so cheap.

I had a picky treater myself so I tried just about anything under the sun. Well least at the beginning, now she'll work for broccoli.

Dog food rolls are these things

http://www.amazon.com/Redbarn-Pet-Products-Beef-Food/dp/B00008DFOG

There are a bunch of different brand names but it's just this big roll of semi-wet dog food. You just cut like 1/4" off the end, chop it in tiny pieces and use it for training treats. Keep the rest of the roll refrigerated. They are kind of like puppy crack and really cheap for the number of treats you get.