What is Reddit's opinion of The Master of Disguise: My Secret Life in the CIA?

From 3.5 billion Reddit comments

My uncle was covert. Officially, his cover story was that he worked in "embassy security". After he died I asked my aunt about him. She wouldn't say much, but she said that he really liked this book for its accurate portrayal.

Gathering and analyzing intelligence on other countries is its primary, original role. Most directly for keeping specifically the President informed of just what the heck is developing around the world. It was started after WW2 in order to prevent another Pearl Harbor surprise. And they were not allowed to gather intelligence on US soil, but that has not been strictly observed.

This work involves gathering tasks as mundane as always reading the news in a target country, as political context matters as much as tapped phone conversations when putting together an analysis. But the movie-caliber stuff is important too. They tap phones, recruit sources in governments and industry, build a whole network of resources.

To collect this information, the CIA uses two kinds of employees. “Official cover” officers pose as diplomats in US embassies worldwide. All embassy staff will be under surveillance from the target country’s counter-intelligence organizations — their FBI equivalents — so meeting sources is risky and they might stick to less blatant parts of the job. But on the upside, they have diplomatic immunity and just get sent home if caught spying. Non-official cover officers get jobs in multinational companies or assume some invented identity that gives them a reason to be in country. They can more freely recruit local sources but must rot in prison or die if caught, unacknowledged.

Info goes back to legions of analysis teams working in offices in the US who prepare it into reports.

The CIA also engages in covert and clandestine activities meant to influence other countries. This latter role has grown, diminished, and changed in nature throughout its history depending on political climate. Some bad press from some really ugly leaks in the 70’s (I think) about the extent of these activities put a big damper on them for a while, requiring Presidential sign-offs on killings, iirc. Post 9/11, the CIA is back on the hard stuff but keeps a legion of lawyers to make sure it’s teccchhnically legal.

These cold war activities include funding and organizing Afghan resistance against communist rule, for example. A whole covert war. Also tons of election rigging, assassination, etc. Post cold war they have been involved in anti-terror activities like running the war against the Taliban and assassinating militants and their neighbors with drone missiles.

Fun fact: “covert” operations are meant to hide who is behind an operation, “clandestine” are meant to conceal the entire operation from anyone but us. Compare an assassination to a phone tap.

Edit: in one episode (2 or 3 i think) of Netflix docu series Inside the Mossad explains how Israel’s foreign intelligence uses elaborate sting operations to recruit sources. By the time they realize they’re working for Mossad, they’re in too deep to not go along with it. Intelligence orgs do this a lot when they know the people they need probably hate the org’s country. This is basically all the time for Israel spying on other middle east states. Case officers often use really impressively manipulative strategies for recruiting and controlling their local agents. “The Americans” illustrates some great examples of this, if a little more dramatic.

Edit 2A: There are a bunch of other specialized US foreign intelligence agencies, like the NSA that traditionally intercepts signals and cracks their codes.

Edit 2B: In the UK, MI6 of James Bond fame does foreign intelligence and MI5 does counter-intelligence. These existed during WW2 but back then the lines got blurred, with both organizations running their own double agents against Nazi Germany’s own two competing foreign intelligence orgs. In fact, 0% of any spies Germany sent to Britain were able to work for enough time before being caught to send anything useful over. By 1944, when the UK was more confident that they were controlling all the sources sending info to Germany (the ones that wouldn’t work for the UK as double agents radioing harmless intel back home were either dead or imprisoned), they fed Germany massive misinformation about the location (and timing?) of the D-Day Normandy invasion. Read the excellent book Operation Double Cross to learn about this incredible operation.

BOOK EDIT:

Books on the CIA I found rewarding.

“The Master of Disguise” by Tony Mendez. Ben Affleck played him in Argo. Memoir of this artist’s time in the CIA inventing disguises and forging travel documents, often to exfiltrate an exposed source. Watch or read Argo too if you haven’t, the film at least is incredibly cool because its evacuation of American diplomats from Iran as Canadian filmmakers is largely real. https://www.amazon.com/Master-Disguise-Secret-Life-CIA/dp/0060957913/

“Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA.” Recent declassifications are exposing just how terribly the CIA bungled things in the early cold war, which is what this is about. From massive nuclear arms race miscalculations that threatened the world, to unfounded communism paranoia that led to totally unnecessary coups, they used classification to hide their greatest errors. https://www.amazon.com/dp/0307389006/

“Spycraft: The Secret History of the CIA's Spytechs, from Communism to Al-Qaeda.” Beyond just the tech, you get insight into the lives of tech team members who would bug homes for their career. Interesting stuff. I think I read a different edition but this is probably fine. https://www.amazon.com/dp/0452295475/

“Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and Bin Laden, from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001” Tom Clancy name, but actually an extremely detailed history of the CIA’s 1980’s support for Afghan mujahideen against the USSR and continued involvement in the 90’s. Down to highlighting cultural generational differences within the multiple cohorts of CIA officers in charge of the long-running operation. Also highlights Pakistan’s demand to hand out all the money, both to act as kingmaker for the dominant factions and to skim hella bux off the top. Descriptions of the conflict and how the Afghans relentlessly persevered and how factions had independent deals and truces with USSR. Then much of the civil war aftermath of USSR pullout when the US stopped caring. Taliban become popular for not tolerating warlords raping local boys, an issue that remains to this day among US supported administration (a coalition of “former” warlords who you will recognize if you read the book). Great read, incredible breadth. https://www.amazon.com/dp/0143034669/

Master of Disguise is Mendez's memoir. Pretty revealing about his capabilities.

You can also read Tony’s books,

The Master of Disguise: My Secret Life in the CIA https://www.amazon.com/dp/0060957913/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_tai_XLXZBb54T2120

Spy Dust: Two Masters of Disguise Reveal the Tools and Operations that Helped Win the Cold War https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000FC0UQC/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_tai_rOXZBbD115EQX

Argo: How the CIA and Hollywood Pulled Off the Most Audacious Rescue in History https://www.amazon.com/dp/0147509734/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_tai_POXZBbNX1N9MF

His book is fantastic, and has lots of great pictures as well.

https://www.amazon.com/Master-Disguise-Secret-Life-CIA/dp/0060957913

Mendez's memoir is a great read for more fun facts. <em>Master of Disguise</em>

So you're saying you're offering me a million dollars to run Rick Harrison's pawn shop and assume his identity? Or just change my name to "Rick Harrison" and run some other pawn shop and have to put up with customers making corny jokes at my expense every waking minute of the work day?

Option one, I don't think even Tony Mendez could help me pull it off. Option 2? Eh, maybe. If anyone is interested, here's an article from the National Pawnbroker's Association called Tips for Opening a Pawn Shop:

>Another thing you will need immediately, before the front door opens for the first time, is sufficient knowledge and tools to test and identify precious metals and gemstones. In most pawnbroking operations, fine jewelry accounts for over 50% of items pledged for a pawn loan or offered for sale. If at least someone in your business cannot identify a diamond from a moissanite or a solid gold ring from a heavily plated ring, you will have an extremely difficult road ahead of you. Plus you should also consider having a marketing system in place to attract qualified customers into your pawnshop and keep them returning again and again.

How much does a GIA-trained gemologist want for a salary? Can I get access to the real Rick Harrison's address book of expert contacts as part of the deal?

I think this is more responsibility than I'm game for right now, but for 1 million it might be worth trying. lol

The book it's taken from is a really good read. &quot;Master of Disguise,&quot; which covers not only that event in Iran but the rest of the author's career with the CIA.